Multiple anion chemistry is of particular interest for preparing materials with new structures and exciting physical properties, including energy storage materials. Through careful synthesis optimization, a new Na2Fe2OS2 phase was prepared by two different routes: high temperature solid-state synthesis and simple mechanochemical synthesis. The long-range and local structure of Na2Fe2OS2 was studied by Rietveld refinement of neutron and X-ray diffraction data combined with EXAFS data refinement. The phase comprises an amorphous and a crystalline part which has an anti-K2NiF4 structure, corresponding to the n = 1 member of the homologous anti-Ruddlesden-Popper [AX][ABX3]n series. Its electrochemical properties as a cathode material were studied in Na half cells and Na-ion full cells, revealing that the material becomes fully amorphous upon initial desodiation to Na0.5Fe2OS2, but maintains a reversible capacity of 135 mAh·g-1 in full cells and a good cyclability. The stability of the pristine material and its structural evolution upon charging are discussed, paving the way for further optimization of this material. Being composed exclusively of earth-abundant elements and stable under dry air, Na2Fe2OS2 perfectly illustrates the great opportunity of multiple anion chemistry to explore new structure types and develop better energy storage systems.